The full set of analysis can be found here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzEoTkR5HCWhTlFsY3k0Y1IzWlE/view?usp=share_link&resourcekey=0-43aaHBAVgWE0JxllK6FFOg
Here is a short version of the 2013 survey results....
This is a summary of the results of a survey which I launched in September 2013. There were 121 respondents who completed the survey, predominantly from the USA and the UK , but also Europe, Canada , Australia , India and South Africa
Mobility Analysis
Answers were given by 116 respondents. Just over half of respondents use walking sticks/poles/crutches/canes and around a third of respondents use a wheelchair or mobility scooter. FES is the mobility aid used by the least number of people, with a take-up of around 5%.
Mobility Aids Used - Summary:
|
Respondents
|
Percentage
|
Using sticks/poles/crutches/canes
|
62
|
53%
|
Using Wheelchair/Mobility Scooter
|
40
|
34%
|
Using Orthotics/AFO
|
33
|
28%
|
Using Walking Frame/Rollator
|
31
|
27%
|
Using
|
7
|
6%
|
In the remainder of this paper whenever “sticks” are referred to as a mobility aid this term includes poles, crutches and canes. Whenever “frames” are referred to this includes both walking frames and rollators. Whenever “chairs” are referred to this includes both wheelchairs and mobility scooters. Whenever AFO is mentioned it refers to Orthotics and AFO.
The results also allow the distribution of respondents within a scale of mobility. I have devised an “HSP mobility score” which then allows me to cross-reference mobility against the other questions in the questionnaire. The definition of the HSP mobility score is;
- Can walk without aids but some effects
- Orthotics/AFO/FES and/or Sticks/Poles/Crutches/Canes some of the time
- Sticks/Poles/Crutches/Canes and Frame/Chair some of the time
- Sticks/Poles/Crutches/Canes most of the time
- Sticks/Poles/Crutches/Canes all of the time
- Rollator/Walking frame most of the time
- Rollator/Walking frame all of the time
- Wheelchair/Mobility scooter most of the time
- Wheelchair/Mobility scooter all of the time
Change in Mobility
One question asked people to describe how their mobility had changed over the last five years. I interpreted these results such that anyone who was either developing their first symptoms or gaining an increase in mobility score by up to around 2 was described as having a “low” change in mobility. Those who gained an increase in mobility score of around 3-4 would have a “medium” change in mobility, and those with an increase greater than around 4 would have a “high” change in mobility. 81 respondents provided enough information for me to attempt an interpretation, as shown in the following table.
5 Year Change in Mobility
|
Respondents
|
Percentage
|
Low
|
62
|
77%
|
Medium
|
17
|
21%
|
High
|
2
|
2%
|
This shows that generally changes in mobility are quite slow, with the majority (three quarters) of respondents having a low change over 5 years. There are a small number of patients, probably less than 5%, who will experience significant changes in mobility over a five year period.
Symptoms Analysis
I found 13 symptoms which occur often in descriptions of HSP and asked respondents if these symptoms were an issue for them or not. For each symptom respondents selected the most appropriate from a list of choices, which I have grouped into severity bands;
Severity
|
Severity Band
|
Do not have
|
-
|
Occasional symptom
|
Minor
|
Minor symptom
|
Minor
|
Frequent symptom
|
Significant, Moderate
|
Regular symptom
|
Significant, Moderate
|
Most of the time
|
Significant, Major
|
All of the time
|
Significant, Major
|
The following table shows the percentage of respondents with each of the symptoms, ordered by frequency – the most frequently occurring severe symptoms at the top.
Symptom
|
Do not have
|
Minor
|
Significant
|
Loss of balance
|
4
|
26
|
70
|
More stiff in the cold
|
4
|
29
|
67
|
Fatigue
|
8
|
30
|
62
|
Bladder problems
|
18
|
39
|
43
|
Stress
|
19
|
42
|
39
|
Back pain
|
22
|
42
|
36
|
Clonus (jumping feet)
|
30
|
37
|
34
|
Numbness
|
31
|
36
|
33
|
Depression
|
34
|
34
|
32
|
Bowel problems
|
39
|
36
|
25
|
Loss of vibration sensitivity in legs
|
39
|
37
|
24
|
Pes cavus
|
48
|
15
|
38
|
Hammer toes
|
53
|
18
|
28
|
This shows that the two symptoms which affect people the most are loss of balance and getting more stiff when it is cold, which is a significant issue for 70% of respondents, and an issue for more than 95% of respondents. Fatigue affects more than 90% of respondents and is a significant issue for more than 60%.
Bladder problems, stress and back pain affect around 80% of respondents, significantly in about half of those. Clonus, numbness and depression affect around 70% of respondents, and show a similar pattern where half of those affected are significantly so.
Bowel problems and loss of vibration sensitivity affect around 60% of respondents. These symptoms appear to be significant for a smaller proportion of respondents. Pes cavus and hammer toes affect the smallest proportion of respondents, around 50%, and these symptoms appear to be significant for a greater proportion of respondents.
Symptoms - Analysis of Symptoms against Mobility
For a more detailed analysis I grouped the respondents into groups according to mobility;
Number of Symptoms – walking unaided
Those who can walk unaided tend to have 4-5 minor symptoms, up to three moderate symptoms and no major symptoms. All respondents in this group had at least three symptoms, at least two of which were minor.
Minor symptoms are likely to include Loss of Balance, Stiffness in the Cold and Fatigue, and may include Bladder problems, Stress, Back Pain, Clonus, Numbness or Bowel problems. Moderate or major problems may include Stiffness in the Cold, Fatigue, Stress, Back Pain, Clonus or Numbness.
Number of Symptoms – use aids some of the time
Those who use mobility aids some of the time tend to have 4-5 minor symptoms, up to three moderate symptoms and up to one major symptom. All of the respondents in this group had at least five symptoms, at least one of which was minor.
Minor symptoms are likely to include Loss of Balance, Stiffness in the Cold and Fatigue, and may include Bladder problems, Stress, Back Pain, Clonus, Numbness or Bowel problems. Moderate or major problems may include Stiffness in the Cold, Fatigue, Stress, Back Pain, Clonus or Numbness.
Number of Symptoms – using mobility aids all or most of the time
Those who use mobility aids all or most of the time tend to have 2-5 minor symptoms, up to 5 moderate symptoms and up to 5 major symptoms. All of the respondents in this group had at least 7 symptoms.
Minor symptoms may include Bladder problems, Stress, Back Pain, Clonus, Numbness, Depression, Bowel Problems and loss of vibration sensitivity in the legs. Moderate or major problems may include Loss of Balance, Stiffness in the Cold, Bladder problems, Stress, Depression, Bowel Problems, Pes Cavus or Hammer Toes.
Mis-diagnoses
One question asked people what they had been diagnosed with before getting their HSP diagnosis. 100 respondents answered this question. 20 respondents indicated that they had been correctly diagnosed with HSP the first time.
The 80 respondents who had been mis-diagnosed gave in total 126 different misdiagnoses. Some respondents listed just one misdiagnosis, whereas others listed a great many. In total there were 59 different conditions listed. Twelve of these were given at least three times accounting for nearly 60% of mis-diagnoses, as shown in the following table;
Mis-diagnosis
|
Number of diagnoses
|
Multiple Sclerosis (MS)
|
19
|
Cerebral Palsy
|
12
|
Arthritis
|
6
|
Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT)
|
6
|
Neuropathy
|
5
|
Ataxia
|
4
|
Motor Neurone disease - Primary Lateral Sclerosis (PLS)
|
4
|
Cerebral Palsy - Spastic Diplegia
|
4
|
Muscular Dystrophy (MD)
|
3
|
Motor Neurone disease - Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
|
3
|
Peripheral Neuropathy
|
3
|
Spinocerebellar Ataxia
|
3
|
Like this? in other years:
Overview of all my surveys: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/p/my-on-line-resarch.html
2016: Fatigue, bladder, bowel & information: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2017/02/2016-survey-results.html
2015: Modifications at home, depression, quality of life: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/2015-survey-results.html
2014: Medication, exercise & relaxation: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2015/02/2014-survey-results.html
Overview of all my surveys: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/p/my-on-line-resarch.html
2016: Fatigue, bladder, bowel & information: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2017/02/2016-survey-results.html
2015: Modifications at home, depression, quality of life: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/2015-survey-results.html
2014: Medication, exercise & relaxation: http://hspjourney.blogspot.co.uk/2015/02/2014-survey-results.html
